Jeffrey Dahmer detective Michael Dubis opened the refrigerator. “There was a human head in a cardboard box looking at me.”
In July 1991, Michael Dubis was a homicide detective on the Milwaukee Police Department's midnight shift. He and his partner, Detective Pat Kennedy, were sent to an apartment where officers had found Polaroid pictures of dismembered bodies. Jeffrey Dahmer was handcuffed on the floor when they walked in.
Mike describes what detectives found once they had permission to search, including about 84 Polaroid pictures and an apartment with a strong, sweet chemical smell. He explains why neighbors' complaints never reached police, and how the victims were identified, many of them by Dahmer himself from photographs.
He also says the six months after the arrest were the hardest of his married life, and it wasn't because of what he saw. It was how the media treated his department, in a year when records were still kept on 3x5 cards and manual typewriters.
Timestamps:
0:00 — Michael Dubis, Milwaukee Homicide
1:29 — The Call on the Midnight Shift
4:27 — The Handcuffed Man Who Got Away
8:00 — 84 Polaroids and a Chest Freezer
11:12 — Why Wasn't He Caught Sooner?
17:20 — A Police Family and the Hardest Six Months
19:42 — The May 1991 Call and the Media Backlash
24:02 — How 17 Victims Were Identified
In Part 2: what the case cost the detectives who worked it, a psychiatrist who had seen one autopsy, and Officer Michael Michalski.
👍 If you support law enforcement stories told with honesty and context, like, subscribe, and share.
🔔 Turn on notifications so you don't miss Part 2.
💬 Drop a comment below — what moment from this episode hit you hardest?
📋 Watch the full playlist: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL2wve6lDC8CG05NH7uNQXc2fS8aW_hOeY&si=yvaW_8jLlr7q1D5L
🔗 Part 2: https://youtu.be/ReekjrtEXCM
🌐 Listen to the audio version at: https://heroesbehindthebadge.com/
© 2026 Citizens Behind the Badge. All Rights Reserved.
Keywords:
Michael Dubis, Milwaukee homicide detective, Milwaukee Police Department, Dahmer case, Dahmer investigation, Dahmer arrest 1991, Dahmer apartment, Milwaukee Cannibal, Pat Kennedy detective, serial killer investigation, homicide investigation, crime scene evidence, identifying victims, missing persons, police and the media, media criticism of police, police family, true crime interview, law enforcement podcast, police interview